Discussion: View Thread

  • 1.  Intellectuals aren't supposed to have humor?

    Posted 02-04-1997 19:10
    >Suggest you get familiar with the delete button...thought this was an
    >intellectual list serve

    So, am I getting this right... to be intellectual you must have no
    humor??? If this reasoning is on target, if you want to be an
    "intellectual," don't have any sense of humor.

    Hmmm maybe my 3 - I Q test scores were inaccurate. ;-(

    --
    Best Regards,

    Pat Gantt pagantt@worldnet.att.net Pat@HomeMail.com
    The University of Tennessee M.S. Human Resource Development
    Electronic Performance Instructor Information Source Locator (ISL)


  • 2.  Intellectuals aren't supposed to have humor?

    Posted 02-07-1997 03:55
    >>Suggest you get familiar with the delete button...thought this was an
    >>intellectual list serve
    >
    >So, am I getting this right... to be intellectual you must have no
    >humor??? If this reasoning is on target, if you want to be an
    >"intellectual," don't have any sense of humor.
    >
    >Hmmm maybe my 3 - I Q test scores were inaccurate. ;-(
    >
    >--
    >Best Regards,
    >
    >Pat Gantt pagantt@worldnet.att.net Pat@HomeMail.com
    >The University of Tennessee M.S. Human Resource Development
    >Electronic Performance Instructor Information Source Locator (ISL)
    >

    Hey guys, please forget it !
    A little bit of humour doesn't harm anyone. And, just for the record, half
    of the story is true. If you don't believe me, try and work for a year or so
    in an European country. You now the saying: "You may destroy this paper, but
    before make three copies for the files".

    Best regards,

    Mihai Zsigmond

    PS. I'm not an "intellectual," I'm just an engineer.
    ***********************************************
    Mihai Zsigmond
    Information Centre Officer
    International Management Foundation
    6-8 Povernei street
    71124 Bucharest Romania
    tel: (40 1) 210 5636, 210 5669
    fax: (40 1) 211 1937
    e-mail:fiman@sunu.rnc.ro
    ****************************************************


  • 3.  Intellectuals aren't supposed to have humor?

    Posted 02-07-1997 16:43
    I have been watching this list with interest for some time now,
    enjoying the repartee, and printing off screeds of messages,
    supposedly for later reference. Now, it's time to join in....

    Humour is an important part of our lives, and I find it difficult
    to operate in the learning environment without humour. My premise
    is that students learn better, enjoy a class, and have greater
    interaction with others if there is shared laughter. But
    here we strike a problem - does the humour of one person (or indeed
    culture) relate to the humour of another (person or culture)?

    The second question that is raised is, "What is the function of
    humour?" At a recent conference in Communication, one speaker
    discussed four different classifications of humour: cognition
    ("jumping" or cognitive reframing); incongruence ("bumping" or
    smoothing out the unexpected); superiority ("lumping" or in-groups and
    out-groups); and finally psychoanalysis ("dumping" when humour becomes
    a coping mechanism).

    The difficulty of cross-cultural humour is highlighted by the
    following case, (though will you American's understand Kiwi
    colloquilisms?):

    ...my Chinese student, wasa struggling with English, and needed to
    resit a test. I wanted to affirm the correctness of his second
    attempt so I ticked every answer as we moved down the page, saying as
    I went, "Spot on, spot on, spot on." At the bottom of the page I
    looked at this solemn young man and said, "Do you know what spot on
    means?" " Yes", he replied, "It means the end of a sentence."

    I cannot live without humour, but for it to be functional in a
    training situation, I need to get it right!

    And just for those of you who are waiting for a joke:

    Do you know about the post modernist Mafia?
    They make you an offer you can't understand.


    SS

    Sandy Millar
    Manukau Institute of Technology
    Private Bag 94006, MANUKAU, NZ.
    email: smillar@manukau.ac.nz