Discussion: View Thread

  • 1.  How Do You Become a Good Teacher?

    Posted 10-16-1997 14:13
    On 16 Oct 97 at 14:53, Puetz, Linda wrote:

    > Dear MG-ED-DV Colleagues--
    > I've been approached by a friend who is an well-known expert in his
    > field but has great difficulty teaching others (and his ineffective
    > teaching is consistently reflected in his evaluations :-( ). He's asked
    > me for advice on improving his teaching style and methods of
    > presentation.

    I've done a good deal of teacher (as in school), instructor (as in
    college) and training for trainers. I would use a
    observation/coaching approach, preferably structured, and then
    consider some practice sessions of very short duration to practice
    the various skill sets. Perhaps a starting point is a) to identify a
    good teaching/training skill resource book and b) to identify a few
    models for the individual to observe (the more the better). You may
    want to find models for specific skills..for example Tom Peters video
    for entertainment/movement/expression etc, someone else for
    questioning/dialogue skills, etc.

    Once the person has demonstrated some degree of mastery of separate
    skills, and is showing improvement, you might like at structured
    videotaped feedback sessions, but only after there is mastery to a
    degree. A caution that this technique should be used by someone
    familiar with the dynamics of the techniques (such as the cosmetic
    effect).


    The skill books I am familiar with and would recommend are likely out
    of print so they wouldn't be helpful but perhaps someone can lend an
    oar.
    >
    Robert Bacal, Inst.For Cooperative Communication, rbacal@escape.ca
    Visit our Resource Centre for articles on mgmt.,training,communication, and defusing hostility
    at http://www.escape.ca/~rbacal (204) 888-9290
    *Site Last Updated On Sept.11, 1997*


  • 2.  How Do You Become a Good Teacher?

    Posted 10-16-1997 15:54
    Dear MG-ED-DV Colleagues--
    I've been approached by a friend who is an well-known expert in his
    field but has great difficulty teaching others (and his ineffective
    teaching is consistently reflected in his evaluations :-( ). He's asked
    me for advice on improving his teaching style and methods of
    presentation.

    I'd very much appreciate it if you would take a minute to share any
    ideas, resources, previous mentoring success stories, or perhaps just
    how you yourself learned to teach most effectively. Please post back to
    the list or respond to me privately at <lpuetz@cmh.edu>. Thanks so much
    for your help.

    Linda Puetz
    lpuetz@cmh.edu
    Education Specialist
    Children's Mercy Hospital
    Kansas City, Missouri USA


  • 3.  How Do You Become a Good Teacher?

    Posted 10-16-1997 19:27
    Linda,

    Teaching is something I care very deeply about. Thus, when I saw your request
    for input, I was eager to contribute my thoughts. I hope they help.

    I believe that three experiences (one kind of unusual) have contributed to the
    success I've had as an instructor: teaching communications; performing before
    audiences; and experience teaching young children who require higher levels of
    empathy.

    Teaching communications at Arizona State made me aware of the many subtle
    details that stand between my understanding of the topic and the student's
    developing understanding of the information I'm sharing. These subtleties
    effect both my general presentation of the material (e.g. slides and visuals
    used; use of eye contact; use of gesture; facial expression; vocal tones (for
    emphasis and attention); effective distribution of eye contact; etc.) I've
    found many instructors that cognitively know much about these things, and yet,
    aren't intimately in touch with their own subtle body and other nonverbal cues.

    Performing before the public taught me about managing energy levels with an
    audience. Though, ideally, many if not most instructors want to sit back and
    rely on the student's responsibility for the material to retain attention, the
    fact is that students often take courses they NEED or are REQUIRED to take as
    often as courses that they personally desire raw knowledge of. Thus, to be
    effective, I view one of my major responsibilities as setting the energy level
    in the room: too low and I get inattention; too high, and they don't retain...
    I view it as my responsibility to present the material dynamically, and to truly
    identify the angle on the material that my students will best identify as
    important in their own minds. Thus, I view my teaching from a "performance"
    perspective.

    Finally, empathy. I find that many of us forget, or never experienced what the
    average student faces in a college course. Most of us moved onto this level
    because of our success as students. Most of us understood and retained
    information more easily then the average student does. Thus, it's often
    difficult to identify with "why" the student doesn't easily understand what
    came/comes so easily to us. Yet, this is exactly the key to making the first
    two points effective. We must listen to our students in the classroom, and find
    the way to rephrase the material in a language that they find some intuitive
    contact with. It often requires several tries; but with practice, we can become
    very effective at anticipating the language that they need to hear the material
    in.

    Thus, I urge anyone seeking to improve their teaching to: a) seek a good text,
    or course in business communication (this is usually directly oriented to our
    style of presentation in the classroom moreso than a more general communication
    course/text); b) to view their time in front of the class as a "form" of
    performance presentation, and to control the energy level in the class: raising
    it when necessary, lowering it when the kids get too excited. Finally, c) I
    recommend a very focused effort on understanding the thinking of the "average"
    student.

    I hope there is something in the above that proves useful to your friend.

    Bruce T. Teague
    The Wharton School
    Department of Management
    2055 Steinberg Hall-Dietrich Hall
    University of Pennsylvania
    Philadelphia, PA 19104-6374
    (215)898-1224


  • 4.  How Do You Become a good teacher?

    Posted 10-17-1997 11:22
    Automatic digest processor wrote:

    > Linda Peutz wrote:

    > Dear MG-ED-DV Colleagues--
    > I've been approached by a friend who is an well-known expert in his
    > field but has great difficulty teaching others (and his ineffective
    > teaching is consistently reflected in his evaluations :-( ). He's
    > asked me for advice on improving his teaching style and methods of
    > presentation.
    >

    Linda, in response to you requesting advice about your colleague, I
    would suggest first having him determine how his students see him: what
    they don't like about his style, what they would like to see instead,
    how he makes them feel when he is teaching, etc. In other words, just as
    good teachers come in different packages, so do those on the other end
    of the acceptance scale.

    As difficult as it may be, I also suggest that he sit down with a group
    of his students and ask them these questions point blank, telling them
    why he is asking and noting the poor ratings he gets. And, if he can't
    do it this way or feels that his students might not be as frank as he
    would want, he could have them anonymously write out their responses.
    What he does next would depend on the feedback.

    More generally, the discussion on treating students as "customers" or
    otherwise seems to me to be beside the point if we are talking about
    teacher effectiveness. Either type of teacher could be effective
    depending on how he/she comes across to students. It seems to me that
    however teachers and educators profess their style to be, the real proof
    is in the feedback they get from their students.

    There will always be a discrepancy between how we think we come off to
    others and how others see us, complicated by the fact that there are
    many subsets of the "others". I would think that however we think we
    treat our students, we need feedback from them on a regular basis about
    how they see us treating them.




    Bernard Liebowitz, PhD
    Management Consultants to Business and Industry
    Chicago, Illinois
    website} www.liebowitzassoc.com
    e-mail} bernie@liebowitzassoc.com
    tel} 773/334-2003
    fax} 773/334-2004


  • 5.  How Do You Become a Good Teacher?

    Posted 10-20-1997 12:41
    In response to Linda Puetz's posting re: how to help improve a friend's
    teaching style and methods of presentation.

    We have worked extensively with people (like your friend) who are subject
    experts
    who must take on the role of occasional teacher, which does not come
    naturally to them. Our Learning Watch program is designed to evaluate and
    improve existing training programs. We observe the subject expert during a
    training session, either on-site or remotely, and generate a customized
    report that contains ideas and concepts to incorporate into present and
    future programs. Then our Mentoring service can be used to guide your friend
    through the development and delivery of a future program.

    At Knowledge Plus, a training and development consulting firm, one of our
    major areas of concentration is our work with subject matter experts who
    need to teach or present.
    We have many success stories we could relate to you or your friend about our
    programs that are working to prepare subject experts for this challenging role.

    Regards,
    Peter L. Katz
    President
    Knowledge Plus
    914 225 5888
    fax 914 225 8334

    "Educating SMEs to be effective occasional trainers !!"