Discussion: View Thread

Academic Textbooks or Popular Audience

  • 1.  Academic Textbooks or Popular Audience

    Posted 12-07-1998 15:25
    > On 7 Dec 98 at 14:07, David Miron wrote:
    >
    > > Robert Bacal wrote (in response to the first paragraph below):
    >
    > > Frankly, I ain't all that keen on supposedly legitimate academics
    > > that water down research and make it "easy"..."
    > >
    > > I am puzzled. Are you (Robert) making these comments having read
    > > Kohn? Are you making comments based on the idea that he has made
    > > some of his writing "accessible"? I was under the impression that he
    > > has done a tremendous amount of research as the basis for his
    > > writing. What's up?
    >
    > David, the experimental research on the effects of rewards and
    > reinforcement on intrinsic and extrinsic motivation has been around
    > for, literally, decades. It's just that it hasn't been popularized
    > before in a format that is more accessible to people with little or
    > no understanding of psychology.

    Was the book on preventing conflict in the workplace written for the small
    market of academics versed in the empirically-grounded research from
    organizational or social psychology, or was and effort made to try to popularize
    the manuscript into the language of a larger market of managers in the workplace
    with essentially little or no understanding of the empirical research I can only
    assume underlies the conclusions drawn?

    Just curious about the process before I can accept casting aspersions and
    blanket generalizations at the glass houses of other authors.

    Note: My web address
    http://home.att.net/~Choragus
    __________________________________
    Great Optimism,

    Dutch Driver
    Abilene, TX 79605
    mailto:AskChoragus@yada-yada.com