Discussion: View Thread

  • 1.  impossible course lay-out?

    Posted 02-25-1999 08:15
    Colleagues,

    Can I ask your advise in an impossible (?) educational mission?

    I teach in a social science department, rather than a business school
    environment, in a program that focusses on strategy/policy, communication and
    organisation of both profit and non-profit organisations. The program is
    succesfull in attracting large numbers of students (every year some 150-200
    will finish the program). We wish to do a case-based integration course in
    which to combine and confront our strategy, OT and OB courses, but the number
    of students limits our range of options. Alternative plans are called for. A
    feasible plan (in terms of workload for the teachers) would seem to be the one
    that I will explain below. However, before starting this course in Fall next
    year, I wish to invite your advise on the course lay-out.

    The integration course is to accomodate 200 students who have little
    experience in case work. The course will be taught by three teachers of
    respectively strategy, OT and OB. The course will take 8 weeks, 6 of which are
    available for case analysis. The learning objective is to develop students'
    skills in 'lateral thinking' and in understanding the possibility and value of
    multiple perspectives on organisations. In order to meet this objective, our
    intention is to offer two cases, one of which is used for class discussion,
    the other as a parallel assignment on which the students receive their grades.
    The students are split in three groups each of which takes one perspective
    (strategy, OT or OB) for two weeks. These groups are further split up such
    that about 20 student participate in a class discussion. After two weeks they
    change their focus. After six weeks the three groups have applied the three
    different perspectives on one single case. Parallel to the class discussion of
    the first case, the students work individually on the second case.

    Me and my colleagues would very much appreciate your advice on the following
    questions:
    1) Has anybody experience with such a course format or lay-out? If so, how did
    it work and what preconditions are to be met for this format to be succesful?
    2) How do you consider the chances of students to appreciate the format and to
    learn something? Why?
    3) Any suggestions for cases that are rich enough to be interesting from both
    the strategy, OT and OB perspectives?

    Please respond to me personally. I will put together a summary of your advice
    and redistribute this to the list.

    Yours,

    Frank den Hond

    Vrije Universiteit - SCW / P&B / BCO
    De Boelelaan 1081c
    1081 HV Amsterdam
    the Netherlands

    tel.: +31 20 444 6818 / 6805
    fax: +31 20 444 6820


  • 2.  impossible course lay-out?

    Posted 03-05-1999 17:18
    I agree that you have an impossible task here. However, an inexpensive
    book that should be very helpful for the students is "Learning with
    cases," by Louise Mauffette-Leenders, Jim Erskine, & Mike Leenders;
    published by the Ivey School, University of Western Ontario, London,
    Ontario, Canada. Their USA price is US$16 for individual copies, or $12
    to bookstores; both plus shipping. It wouldn't surprise me if the
    European Case Clearinghouse at Cranfield is their agent for Europe.

    This book provides a clear, easy to follow approach to case reading and
    analysis. Try it, I think you'll like it. It came out last Spring; I now
    require it for all my students.

    Tim Edlund, Morgan State University, Baltimore, MD USA


  • 3.  impossible course lay-out?

    Posted 03-06-1999 09:22
    Tim,
    I'd be very interested in reviewing this text, but have been unable to find
    it at amazon.com, under any other author's names or the title. Do you
    perchance have the ISBN?
    Many thanks.

    Ken Miller, Instructor Health Care Administration and Management
    School of Business
    College of West Virginia
    kmiller@cwv.net
    miller@cwv.edu
    -----Original Message-----
    From: Tim Edlund <tedlund@MORGAN.EDU>
    To: MG-ED-DV@MAELSTROM.STJOHNS.EDU <MG-ED-DV@MAELSTROM.STJOHNS.EDU>
    Date: Friday, March 05, 1999 6:23 PM
    Subject: Re: impossible course lay-out?


    >I agree that you have an impossible task here. However, an inexpensive
    >book that should be very helpful for the students is "Learning with
    >cases," by Louise Mauffette-Leenders, Jim Erskine, & Mike Leenders;
    >published by the Ivey School, University of Western Ontario, London,
    >Ontario, Canada. Their USA price is US$16 for individual copies, or $12
    >to bookstores; both plus shipping. It wouldn't surprise me if the
    >European Case Clearinghouse at Cranfield is their agent for Europe.
    >
    >This book provides a clear, easy to follow approach to case reading and
    >analysis. Try it, I think you'll like it. It came out last Spring; I now
    >require it for all my students.
    >
    >Tim Edlund, Morgan State University, Baltimore, MD USA


  • 4.  impossible course lay-out?

    Posted 03-06-1999 14:11
    Ken,
    Hope that all's well in the mountains of West Virginia!
    The book "Learning With Cases" that you're interested is listed at:
    http://www.ivey.uwo.ca/IveyPublishing/cps.asp?pvar=AdditionalProducts
    With the following description:
    This soft cover book is a concise handbook written specifically for students
    to enhance their learning with cases. Numerous and helpful suggestions cover
    the complete case learning process including individual reading and
    preparation, small group discussion, large group (classroom) discussion,
    making case presentations and writing case exams and reports. Learning with
    Cases introduces the case difficulty cube and the three stage learning
    process from a student perspective. Students can prepare faster and be more
    effective and confident by completing the short cycle process, the long
    cycle process and the case preparation chart. Other suggestions include how
    students can maximize the benefits of small group discussion and improve
    their classroom contributions. This book is the only one to provide a
    complete, practical and proven process for learning with cases that students
    can apply to any case assignment. Length: 135 pages.
    You can purchase it directly from the Ivey School of the University of
    Western Ontario (which is one of the world's best business schools, of
    course). The link for the main Ivey School page is:
    http://www.ivey.uwo.ca/
    Cybercollegially,
    Charlie Wankel
    listmaster mg-ed-dv
    Academy of Management MED Division Chair-Elect
    wankelc@stjohns.edu

    > Tim,
    > I'd be very interested in reviewing this text, but have been
    > unable to find
    > it at amazon.com, under any other author's names or the title. Do you
    > perchance have the ISBN?
    > Many thanks.
    >
    > Ken Miller,
    >
    > >I agree that you have an impossible task here. However, an inexpensive
    > >book that should be very helpful for the students is "Learning with
    > >cases," by Louise Mauffette-Leenders, Jim Erskine, & Mike Leenders;
    > >published by the Ivey School, University of Western Ontario, London,
    > >Ontario, Canada. Their USA price is US$16 for individual copies, or $12
    > >to bookstores; both plus shipping. It wouldn't surprise me if the
    > >European Case Clearinghouse at Cranfield is their agent for Europe.
    > >This book provides a clear, easy to follow approach to case reading and
    > >analysis. Try it, I think you'll like it. It came out last
    > Spring; I now require it for all my students.
    > >Tim Edlund