Discussion: View Thread

  • 1.  Another way to look at requests from students

    Posted 02-26-1999 14:06
    Hi everyone:

    Staring out my window this morning at 20+ inches of snow (at Chatham, MA, I'm
    at Ground Zero for yesterday's nor'easter; and it's started snowing all over
    again on my freshly shoveled walk), I started thinking about the problem of
    student inquiries (especially those last minute, poorly written, horribly
    conceived emails). And granted: the email we received the other day was a
    thinly veiled request: "Hey, do my homework for me, will ya? I'll just use my
    handy/dandy cut and paste function and call it a term paper."

    As an HR writer with a byline that carries my email address, I also get those
    inquiries. And they can be a nuisance. But I'd like to pose the possibility
    that this "problem" could be harnessable energy.

    To wit: instead of perceiving student requests as a global nuisance, I wonder
    if employers could reframe the situation into one that's a recruitment
    benefit. For instance, the career guidance types all recommend that students
    contact successful people in their field of choice for that "informational
    interview." I don't know about you, but I've always been intimidated by the
    prospect of doing that.

    So we should make it easier for students to come to us! Companies that are
    into heavy recruiting now -- or that expect to be in that mode 4 to 8 years
    from now -- would do well to work in partnership with educational institutions
    of their choice (high school AND college+).

    INVITE students to contact selected employees to ask about the nature of their
    work and skills/education requirements. Coordinate with school department
    heads so that students are equipped with intelligent questions to ask.
    (Granted, at the higher education level, we shouldn't be getting emails of the
    quality we got ss of correspondents.)

    As a writer, it's my business to contact busy businesspeople and say, "gimme
    what you got." But because I'm a writer with 20 years of experience doing it,
    I can couch my request in much more sophisticated language. But, all in all,
    the request is still pretty much the same.

    And I DO remember the early years when my worst fear was asking the stupid
    question. Maybe we can help these kids ask better questions and be rewarded
    with a readier cadre of candidates when they hit the job market: Employees who
    know exactly how to pursue professions that they're going to love and
    contribute to for the rest of their lives.

    Since they're going to hit the job market anyway, the alternative scenario is
    unthinkable.

    Martha Finney
    speaker, co-author, Find Your Calling, Love Your Life (Simon & Schuster, 98)


  • 2.  Another way to look at requests from students

    Posted 02-26-1999 18:02
    Martha has an excellent point. Personally, I send back a series of
    appropriate questions about the topic for the writer to answer first.
    These lists of questions come from my business development course used
    from 1980 to 1995.


    If you would like a copy of these lists (WP 6.0 format only), for your
    own personal use (copyrighted by myself), just ask by email.

    Martha Finney wrote:
    >
    > Hi everyone:
    >

    > To wit: instead of perceiving student requests as a global nuisance, I wonder
    > if employers could reframe the situation into one that's a recruitment
    > benefit. For instance, the career guidance types all recommend that students
    > contact successful people in their field of choice for that "informational
    > interview." I don't know about you, but I've always been intimidated by the
    > prospect of doing that.
    >
    > So we should make it easier for students to come to us! Companies that are
    > into heavy recruiting now -- or that expect to be in that mode 4 to 8 years
    > from now -- would do well to work in partnership with educational institutions
    > of their choice (high school AND college+).
    >
    >
    > Martha Finney
    > speaker, co-author, Find Your Calling, Love Your Life (Simon & Schuster, 98)

    --
    Dick Montgomery, General Manager
    21st Century Co-operative
    Our Mission - "Help You Increase Sales"
    http://www.chemmgrs.com