Discussion: View Thread

  • 1.  Academic Rigour and the Use of Humour

    Posted 04-19-1999 00:52
    At 07:15 pm 16/04/99 Robert Bacal wrote:
    >This conversation, in less than 24 hours has moved from a simple
    >request regarding what I could post to a discussion of whether jokes
    >are ok to whether humor is a good thing in life!

    I took this request as a threat to swamp all discussion lists with
    cross-posts. But ... I don't sweat the little stuff because it ain't
    really that important in the big scheme of things. Hey, I have an idea, we
    could talk about how certain list members seem to hog the discussions,
    which makes it hard to contribute when the USA is "chatting" away whilst
    half-the-world is asleep but ... it ain't really that important in the big
    scheme of things.

    >It's pretty amazing--the drift in the conversation and the additional
    >volume the drift has created.

    It's just like in business (funny that ... ha, ha???). You meet someone at
    the photocopier and tell them a joke. You bump into them in the tea room
    and they tell you a joke as repayment. As for the "drift" in the
    conversation, it's like going to a cocktail party, you start the evening
    conversing about one thing and then the topic "drifts" and you leave
    talking about something else.

    From a pedantic point of view, we could have a philosophical discussion
    about whether jokes and humour are the same thing. I'd argue that they are
    not. If they were, then I wouldn't be a humourous conference speaker
    because I don't tell jokes (but I am humourous). For what it is worth, I
    see nothing wrong with people telling jokes, either verbally or
    electronically.

    From a purely academic point of view we could continue this discussion by
    citing examples of the integration of humour in the workplace at Benny &
    Jerry's, Kodak Eastman, the Birmingham Hospital (UK), et al. That would
    certainly add an element of credibility to the discussion. After all,
    there are many, many, many papers written on the use of humour in the
    workplace. The dearth of literature is in the area of "humour in
    cross-cultural settings". I know this for a fact (and managers like
    dealing with facts). I researched and wrote a paper (unpublished) on this
    very topic about five years ago and discovered this gap in the literature.
    Maybe list members could work together to write a collective paper and turn
    this discussion into a very proactive, community building sort of thing.
    Now, wouldn't that be funny??? (ha, ha).

    Remember, death takes on too much importance when one is not participating
    in life.

    Alan :-)
    ----------------------------------------------------------
    Alan Wilson ~ Facilitated Solutions
    Speaker & Trainer to the Meetings Industry


  • 2.  Academic Rigour and the Use of Humour

    Posted 04-19-1999 11:36
    Why don't we just create a separate parallel list for "Management Humor?"
    Then those who want it can have it and those who don't don't have to be
    overloaded with it?
    Marvin Manheim
    Kellogg
    mlmanheim@nwu.edu


  • 3.  Academic Rigour and the Use of Humour

    Posted 04-19-1999 17:32
    Alan the downunderer wrote:
    Maybe list members could work together to write a collective paper and turn
    this discussion into a very proactive, community building sort of thing.

    Actually that might really be fun. It would be like one of the genetics
    papers with 800 co-authors. The paper could be an appendix to the title
    paper maybe. But what to write on? Certainly the doings here are
    interesting. I mean with people posting from New York to Zimbabwe to Sydney
    to Nepal to Finland to Peru. Yikes. We are a virtual community but--what's
    that Japanese film where everyone has a different angle on the crime?--could
    we all get it together. Would it be in hypertext? We have the archives of
    everything on list. Gadzooks! But you were kidding. Oh well.
    Charlie Wankel
    St. John's University, New York City
    listmaster mg-ed-dv
    wankelc@stjohns.edu


  • 4.  Academic Rigour and the Use of Humour

    Posted 04-21-1999 11:32
    At 05:32 pm 19/04/99 Charles wrote:
    >Actually that might really be fun. It would be like one of the genetics
    >papers with 800 co-authors. The paper could be an appendix to the title
    >paper maybe. But what to write on? Certainly the doings here are
    >interesting. I mean with people posting from New York to Zimbabwe to Sydney
    >to Nepal to Finland to Peru. Yikes. We are a virtual community but--what's
    >that Japanese film where everyone has a different angle on the crime?--could
    >we all get it together. Would it be in hypertext? We have the archives of
    >everything on list. Gadzooks! But you were kidding.

    No I wasn't kidding.

    Alan :-)
    ----------------------------------------------------------
    Alan Wilson ~ Facilitated Solutions
    Speaker & Trainer to the Meetings Industry