Discussion: View Thread

  • 1.  KM as fad - - new article in Wall Street Journal

    Posted 01-07-2003 16:31
    To those interested in the discussion about Knowledge Management as a
    fad, I suggest that you don't overlook an article in today's Wall Street
    Journal. It has some interesting examples to add to the discussion.

    "Learning Gurus Adapt to Escape Corporate Axes", Wall Street Journal,
    Tuesday, January 7, 2003, pp. B1, B4, by David Pringle. (The
    follow-on title to the story is "Chief Knowledge Officers Adapt To
    Remain Relevant, Employed")

    A few excerpts from the article:

    "Where have all the CLOs and CKOs gone? A corporate phenomenon in the
    late 1990s, chief knowledge officers, also called chief learning
    officers, popped up at companies like Pfizer Inc, Coca-Cola... Then
    came the collapsing stock market, corporate belt-tightening... which
    prompted many companies to scrap knowledge-management posts."

    Steve Andriole, as quoted in the article: "CKOs are like a vitamin
    pill. They make you feel good, but in a bear market the only thing that
    really sells is painkillers." He was also quoted as estimating that
    more than 25% of Fortune 500 companies had CKOs at the height of the
    knowledge management boom, but fewer than 20% do now.

    The article gives a few examples of how some CKOs have survived by
    distancing themselves from the knowledge management "craze" while still
    using the concepts of knowledge management. One CKO states that he will
    will not abandon knowledge management, which he considers to be common
    sense, but that he will not call it "knowledge management." The article
    also gives a couple of examples of companies, such as Whirlpool, that
    still overtly use the knowledge management label.

    ----------------------------------------------------
    Shane J. Schvaneveldt, Ph.D.
    Associate Professor of Management
    Goddard School of Business and Economics
    Weber State University
    3802 University Circle
    Ogden, Utah 84408-3802 USA


  • 2.  KM as fad - - new article in Wall Street Journal

    Posted 01-07-2003 21:25
    The article points out a phenomena we experienced with Total Quality
    Management, i.e., we continue to praxes it because it works well and is
    useful, but we call it by another title since it (KM or TQM) is a passe
    buzzword. Top people think these activities are to blame for their troubles,
    when it might be that attitude and their influence on their organizations'
    cultures which might be the real problem.



    '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

    ''
    Ted Rosen, PhD
    Fax: 202/994-4930
    Phone: 301/493-9570
    E-mail: THRosen@aol.com


  • 3.  KM as fad - - new article in Wall Street Journal

    Posted 01-08-2003 08:41
    Rings true to me, Ted. I have to wonder what these
    "top people" have to offer to stimulate their businesses,
    when they put new management approaches up against the
    firing wall? Ah, yes, "fundamentals. Back to basics."

    Davi




    -----Original Message-----
    From: Ted Rosen, Ph.D. [mailto:THRosen@aol.com]
    Sent: Tuesday, January 07, 2003 9:25 PM
    To: MG-ED-DV@MAELSTROM.STJOHNS.EDU
    Subject: Re: [MG-ED-DV] KM as fad - - new article in Wall Street Journal


    The article points out a phenomena we experienced with Total Quality
    Management, i.e., we continue to praxes it because it works well and is
    useful, but we call it by another title since it (KM or TQM) is a passe
    buzzword. Top people think these activities are to blame for their troubles,
    when it might be that attitude and their influence on their organizations'
    cultures which might be the real problem.



    '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

    ''
    Ted Rosen, PhD
    Fax: 202/994-4930
    Phone: 301/493-9570
    E-mail: THRosen@aol.com